Summary of biochemical tests for AF in patients with NAFLD
Parameters Measures | Non-invasive test | AUROC | Cutoff | Diagnostic accuracy (%) | Study population, reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
AST, PLT | APRI score | 0.76 | > 1 | Se 66-Sp91, NPV 87 | 245 NAFLD, [85] |
0.77 | < 1 > 1.5 | Se 50-Sp 84 Se 18.3-Sp 96.1 | 6, 877 NAFLD, [77] | ||
0.86 | 0.42 | Se 84-Sp 75, NPV 96 | 213 T2DM, [46] | ||
Age, AST, ALT, PLT | FIB-4 index | 0.8 | < 1.3 > 2.67 | Se 74-Sp 71 Se 33-Sp 98 | 541 NAFLD, [74] |
0.84 | > 2.67 > 3.25 | Se 26.6-Sp 96.5 Se 31.8-Sp 96 | 8, 635 NAFLD, [77] | ||
0.72 | > 2 | Se 77-Sp 70 | 61 ≥ 65 years NAFLD, [81] (reduced false positive in age > 65 years) | ||
0.84 | < 1 | Se 100-Sp 94.3 (F0 vs. F1-4) | 108 + 239 NAFLD, [83] (excluding any fibrosis) | ||
0.78 | 1.6 | Se 68-Sp 75, NPV 93 | 213 T2DM, [46] | ||
AGE, BMI, albumin, AST/ALT ratio, hyperglycemia, PLT | NFS | 0.84 | > 0.67 < −1.45 | PPV 90 NPV 93 | 733 NAFLD, [75] |
0.84 | < −1.45 | Se 72-Sp 70 | 9, 392 NAFLD, [77] | ||
0.81 | < −1.45 | Se 93-Sp 20 | 61 ≥ 65 years NAFLD, [81] (reduced false positive in > 65 years) | ||
0.64 | < −1.45 –0.053 | Se 91-Sp 40 Se 68-Sp 55, NPV 90 | 69 T2DM, [46] | ||
BMI, T2DM, AST/ALT ratio | BARD score | 0.81 | 2–4 | NPV 96 | 827 NAFLD, [76] |
0.76 | < 2 | Se 76-Sp 61 | 7, 791 NAFLD, [77] | ||
Age, weight, glucose, AST, ALT, ferritin, PLT | FibroMeter | 0.94 | > 0.71 | Se 79-Sp 96, NPV 92 | 235 NAFLD, [85] |
0.81 | Se 88-Sp 93, NPV 92.7 | 938 NAFLD, [86] | |||
Age, weight, glucose, AST, ALT, ferritin, PLT, VCTE | Fibrometer VCTE | 0.86 | 0.32–0.69 | Se 85-Sp 92, NPV 90.7 | 938 NAFLD, [86] |
GGT, bilirubin, haptoglobin, ApoA1, alfa2 macroglobulin | FibroTest® | 0.81 | < 0.3 | NPV 90 | 170 NAFLD + 954 cp, [47] |
0.84 | > 0.7 | PPV 73 | 267 NAFLD, 429 ALD, 724 mixed, [87] | ||
0.85 | < 0.27 | 494 obese, [49] | |||
0.7 | 0.35 | Se 64-Sp 74, NPV 92 | 130 T2DM, [46] | ||
Age, sex, bilirubin, GGT, alfa2-macroglobulin, HA | Hepascore | 0.81 | > 0.37 | Se 75-Sp 84, NPV 92 | 242 NAFLD, [90] |
HA, PIIINP, TIMP-1 | ELF test | 0.9 | > 0.35 | Se 80-Sp 90, NPV 94 | 196 NAFLD, [92] |
0.83 | < 10.18 | Sp 90 | 11 studies (4, 452 NAFLD), [93] | ||
Age, T2DM, PLT, Pro-C3 | ADAPT | 0.87 | > 6.32 | PPV 48.4-NPV 96.6 | 150 + 281 NAFLD, [94] |
Age, BMI, PLT, T2DM | ABC3D | 0.88 | > 3 | Se 77-Sp 82, NPV 84 | 151 discovery cohort NAFLD, [ 95] |
0.81 | Se 66-Sp 75, NPV 80 | 298 validation cohort NAFLD, [95] | |||
TIMP-1, HA, alfa2 macroglobulin | 0.85 | 17 | Se 79-Sp 75, NPV 92 | 396 NAFLD, [96] | |
Type IV collagen S | 0.82 | > 177 | Se 77-Sp 84, NPV 84 | 148 NAFLD, [97] | |
Type IV collagen S, AST | CA index | 0.84–0.91 | 94 + 62 NAFLD, [98] | ||
Mac-2bp, Type IV collagen S | 0.83 | > 0.83 > 5.2 | Se 91-Sp 61, NPV 87 | 165 NAFLD, [100] | |
10 urinary steroid metabolites | GMLVQ analysis | 0.99–1 | 275 NAFLD, [147] | ||
SNP IFNL 4, HOMA-IR, GGT, AST, ALT, PLT | FibroGENE DT | 0.8 | NPV 96 | 488 NAFLD, [158] | |
GUT microbiome model | 0.936 | 86 NAFLD, [159] | |||
Inc RNAs + FIB-4 or TE | 0.89 | 88 + 50 NAFLD, [166] |
GMLVQ: generalized matrix learning vectors quantization; IncRNAs: including long non-coding RNAs; SNP IFNL 4: single nucleotide polymorphism interferon lamba 4; VCTE: vibration controlled transient elastography
The authors thank Giulio Mirabella for his contribution in the graphic support of the production of the figures in this paper.
VR, MM, AA and MP contributed conception and design of the study, VR and MM retrieved and selected the bibliographic references, VR and MM wrote the first draft of the manuscript, AA and MP revised it and wrote specific sessions. All authors contributed to manuscript revision, read and approved the submitted version.
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
© The Author(s) 2020.