Summary of eyelid reconstructive techniques following tumor excision

Surgical techniqueKey featuresAdvantagesDisadvantagesReferences
Autografts
  • For anterior lamellar defects: full-thickness skin graft from upper or lower eyelid, posterior auricular, preauricular, or supraclavicular skin

  • For posterior lamellar defects: palatal mucosa, auricular cartilage, and tarsoconjunctival grafts are the gold standard

  • Resilience and high vascularization

  • Effective conjunctival replacements

  • Less immune response

  • Corneal irritation due to absence of goblet cells and a rough surface

  • Lack of rigidity compared to a native tarsal plate

  • Painful and increased post-op healing period

  • Limited donor area availability

[78, 79]
Cutler-Beard flap
  • Full-thickness cutaneo-conjunctival lower eyelid bridge flap over the upper eyelid, separated a few weeks later

  • No material needed

  • Usable for most defects

  • Effective for large eyelid defects

  • Can be combined with a graft to promote greater stability

  • Entropion

  • Lid margin irregularity

  • Eyelash loss

  • Bridge flap necrosis

  • Eyelid retraction

  • Eyesight problems for people with low visual acuity on the unoperated eye

[8084]
Rotational rhomboid flap
  • A rhomboid-shaped defect is created, consisting of two triangles placed base to base

  • No material needed

  • Minimal complications

  • Useful in challenging medial canthal defect

  • Low traction on the skin

  • Flap can be rotated in multiple directions

  • Stress unevenly distributed

  • Modification in canthal height

[8587]
Mustardé rotational flap
  • First incision made at the lateral canthus all the way up at the level of the eyebrows

  • Second incision vertical to the tragus

  • Minimal skin tension

  • Useful for large defects

  • Can be combined with a posterior lamellar graft

  • Good cosmetic result, low complication rate and low patient morbidity

  • Downward contraction and sagging of the flap

  • Ectropion

  • Need of a septal cartilage mucoperichondrial autograft to reproduce the tarsus

[8890]
Tripier flap
  • Musculocutaneous bipedicle flap from the upper eyelid suspended at both canthi not including the tarsal plate

  • With or without septal cartilage graft

  • Considered one of the best to repair lower-lid retraction or ectropion

  • Good aesthetic and functional results, with excellent color match

  • Low complication rate

  • Less damage to the facial nerve

  • Preserve the continuity of orbicularis muscle fibers

  • Ectropion

  • Epiphora

  • Eyelid edema

  • Lagophthalmos

  • Dry eyes

[91, 92]
Hughes tarsoconjunctival flap
  • Tarsoconjunctival flap from upper eyelid, split at the mucocutaneous junction and attached to the lower lid conjunctiva

  • Flap is Separated few weeks later

  • With or without a skin graft

  • Best used for full-thickness defects of the central portion of the lower lid

  • Good functional and aesthetic results

  • Low complication rate

  • Lower lid margin erythema

  • Lower lid ectropion or entropion

  • Lagophthalmos

  • Infection or flap dehiscence

  • Eyelid retraction

  • Dry eyes

  • Corneal abrasion

[9395]