Summary of recent applications of hydrogels as ocular surface DDS

DiseaseHydrogel compositionDelivery route & active ingredientsStudy phaseRelease durationAdvantages & limitationsReference
Dry eye disease (DED)Aldehyde-functionalized F127Multifunctional antioxidant Cu2-xSe nanoparticlesIn vitro; in vivo (mice)Up to 72 hoursThermosensitive; scavenging of reactive oxygen species; reduced cell damage & apoptosis in cornea and conjunctiva; have not been tested on human patients with DED[60]
Phenylboronic acid-grafted carboxymethyl celluloseGlutathione (GSH)In vitro; in vivo (rabbits)50 hoursReduce inflammation caused by preservative in eye drops (benzalkonium chloride); have not been tested on human patients with DED[90]
CarbomerCyclosporine APhase III clinical trial-Once-a-day treatment for moderate to severe DED; short follow-up duration; long-term safety remains unknown; safety profile compared to other DED topical medications remains unknown; patients with surgery-related DED, drug-related DED, or contact lens wear are excluded from the study[61]
GlaucomaHydroxypropyl methylcelluloseCurcuminIn vitro; in vivo7 daysDecrease inflammation & apoptosis; biocompatible; have only tested biocompatibility on normal animal models; have not tested on animals with glaucoma[24]
ChitosanPilocarpineIn vitro; in vivo (rabbits)Within 4 hourspH-Responsive; burst release that can suppress extreme IOP elevation; prevent damage of endothelium and retinal degeneration 4 hours post-application; the long-term safety profile remains unknown[37]
Mono-methacrylated β-cyclodextrin (β-CD) monomer; HEMAPuerarin; curcuminIn vitroUnder redox conditions: 5 hours; under non-reducing conditions: 6 hoursHighly sensitive to reduced GSH; need to be tested on glaucomatous animal models[36]
Corneal alkali burnHydroxypropyl methylcellulose & sodium hyaluronateImatinibIn vivo (mice)6 hoursAll ingredients used in the formulation are FAD-approved; simple process of formulation preparation; suitable for large-scale production; prompted corneal wound healing & alleviated inflammation; additional anti-scarring drug is needed to achieve greater treatment results[41]
Polyamino acid-based poly-S-nitrosothiols (PGlu-TEPA-SNAP)Nitric oxide (NO)In vitro; in vivo (mice)More than 12 hoursThermosensitive; effective therapeutic effects with minimal ocular complications compared to the traditional dexamethasone treatment; potential application in leptin-based or NO works for ocular therapy; potential application for reluctant corticosteroid therapy of injured cornea[45]
Oxidized chitosan; silk methacrylate (SilMA)Black phosphorus quantum dotsIn vitro; in vivo (mice)-Photocurable; pH-responsive; reduced corneal fibrosis & promoted ocular surface reshaping; neutralized free radicals under acidic conditions[46]
Oxidized chitosan; silk fibroinDNase IIn vitro; in vivo (mouse)7 daysPhotocurable; expedited wound repair through increased migration of corneal stromal cells; the precise mechanism of the neutrophil extracellular trap neovascularization cascade effect remains unclear[47]
Corneal neovascularizationPoloxamer-407 (pluronic F127); oxidized sodium alginateBone morphogenetic protein 4 (BMP4)In vitro; in vivo (rats)More than 72 hoursThermosensitive; applied 3 times a day; reduce inflammation & alleviate corneal edema; reduced production costs; biocompatible[54]
Self-assembling peptideAflibercept (Eylea); cell penetrating peptideIn vitro; in vivo (rabbits)More than 25 hoursNeutralization of the negatively charged Eylea allowed the drug to penetrate the corneal stroma; prevent the formation of new abnormal vessels with minimal effect on normal vessels; potential application for treatment of diabetic retinopathy and AMD[55]

DDS: drug delivery systems; IOP: intraocular pressure; HEMA: hydroxyethyl methacrylate; DNase I: deoxyribonuclease I; AMD: age-related macular degeneration; -: no data