Preclinical studies of gene therapy for CAH to date
Vector and transgene | Model | Dose and route | Key outcome(s) | Longest benefit duration | Reference |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
AdenovirusCYP21A2 | H-2aw18 mice(Cyp21a1-/-) | 1 × 108 pfu/adrenalOpen bilateral intra-adrenal injections | CYP21A2 mRNA expressed in ~ 30% of cortex and medulla, peaking at 2–7 days and still detectable at 14 days.Normalised corticosterone production to 40 days.Improved progesterone/deoxycorticosterone ratio at 7 days but not at 40 days.Transduced adrenals still produced corticosterone ex vivo at 40 days.Improvement in adrenocortical ultrastructure at 7 days. | 40 days | Tajima et al. 1999[62] |
RetrovirusCyp21a1 | H-2aw18 mice(Cyp21a1-/-) fibroblasts | 5 × 105 cells/mouseAutologous subcutaneous transplantation of ex vivo transduced fibroblasts | Four weeks post-implantation, 4 of 6 experimental mice had reduction in progesterone/deoxycorticosterone ratio. | 4 weeks | Naiki et al. 2016[64] |
AAV2Cyp21a1 | H-2aw18 mice(Cyp21a1-/-) | 1 × 1011 vgc/mouseIntra-muscular injection | All mice (n = 4) had reduction in progesterone/deoxycorticosterone ratio (statistically insignificant).One mouse followed to 8 months retained “relatively low” progesterone/deoxycorticosterone ratio until 7 months. | 7 months | |
AAVRh10CYP21A2 | H-2aw18 mice(Cyp21a1-/-) | 2 × 1013 vgc/kgIntravenous injection | Correction in body weight up to 15 weeks.Correction of kidney renin expression at 18 weeks.Urinary progesterone near WT levels up to 15 weeks.Correction in stress response behavioural traits.No correction in adrenocortical morphology. | 18 weeks | Perdomini et al. 2017[5] |
AAVRh10CYP21A2-HA | H-2aw18 mice(Cyp21a1+/+) | 6.5 × 1011 vgc/mouseIntravenous injection | Left adrenal showed waning CYP21A2 expression, from 65% positive cells (2 weeks) to 2.1% positive cells (32 weeks).Liver retained CYP21A2 expression at 32 weeks, while adrenal gland lost expression. | 16 weeks | Markmann et al. 2018[4] |
AAVRh10CYP21A2-HA | H-2aw18 mice(Cyp21a1-/-) | 6.5 × 1011 vgc/mouseIntravenous injection | Progesterone significantly decreased at 2 weeks, no effect by 10 weeks.ACTH decreased from 2–8 weeks, no significant effect by 32 weeks. | 8 weeks | |
AAVRh10CYP21A2 | Cynomolgus macaques | 5 × 1012, 1.5 × 1013, or 4.5 × 1013 vgc/kgIntravenous injection | Detectable vector genomes in adrenals and liver up to 24 weeks (high dose).Transgene expression increased from 4 to 12 weeks, decline evident at 24 weeks (high dose). | 24 weeks | Eclov et al. 2020[66] |
AAV9CYP11B1 | Cyp11b1-/- mice | 1 × 1010 vgc/adrenalIntra-adrenal injection | All mice (n = 4) had significant decrease in serum deoxycorticosterone/corticosterone ratio at 4 weeks.Serum deoxycorticosterone/corticosterone ratio remained low in 2 mice followed to 5 months.No apparent transgene expression in adrenal glands of injected mice11B-hydroxylase activity did not improve (data not shown). | 22 weeks | Naiki et al. 2022[61] |
AAV8CYP21A2 | H-2aw18 mice(Cyp21a1-/-) | 5 × 1011 vgc/mouseIntravenous injection | All mice (n = 10) normalised serum aldosterone and renal renin expression.All mice increased serum corticosterone and reduced adrenal hyperplasia. | 4 weeks | Graves et al. 2024[67] |
AAV: adeno-associated virus; ACTH: adrenocorticotropic hormone; CAH: congenital adrenal hyperplasia; pfu: plaque-forming units; vgc: vector genome copies; WT: wild-type
Figures were created in Biorender.com.
EBVD: Conceptualization, Writing–original draft, Writing–review & editing. SLG and IEA: Validation, Writing–review & editing, Supervision. LEG: Conceptualization, Writing–review & editing, Supervision. All authors read and approved the submitted version.
The authors declare that they have no conflicts of interest.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
Not applicable.
EBVD was supported by the Research Training Program Scholarship, Australian Government. EBVD was additionally supported by the Children’s Medical Research Institute PhD Scholarship. LEG was supported by the Yass Memorial Scholarship, Children’s Medical Research Institute. The funders had no role in study design, data collection and analysis, decision to publish, or preparation of the manuscript.
© The Author(s) 2024.